Public comments: Protecting Learning, A Practical Guide to AI-Use Policy. NYU Tandon School of Engineering.

NYU Tandon has released this guide for public comment. Comments received by Monday, November 30 inform the first revision, planned for January 2027, before the spring semester; we will publish a summary of what we heard and what changed. The form stays open after that date for later revision cycles. Responses are anonymous unless you choose to identify yourself; comments may be quoted without attribution in the public summary. The form takes about five minutes to complete; only the first two questions are required.

About you

Which best describes you?

Please choose one.

What is your affiliation?

Please choose one.

How much of the guide have you read? (optional)

The core recommendations

The guide makes four core recommendations. React to any you have a view on; skip the rest.

1 · Set a baseline, then tune

Set a course-wide baseline using the Red (AI Prohibited), Yellow (Limited AI), and Green (AI-Integrated) labels, then adjust at the assignment level, stating the reasoning in the syllabus.

2 · Expect a profile, not a single color

Most courses end up with different levels for different kinds of work: Green on coding, Yellow on written analysis, Red on quizzes. The labels make that profile legible to students.

3 · Shape it with your students

Bring a starter policy with the non-negotiables explained, put the genuinely open decisions to students through discussion and a vote or other structured input, and keep the final call.

4 · Verify mastery AI-free

Wherever independent mastery matters, add an AI-free check: an oral question, an in-class exam, a proctored quiz. Keep disclosure requirements, but never treat them as sufficient, and never treat AI-detector output as proof of a violation.

Your comment

Free-form comments on the guide, anchored to the part they concern.

Do you expect to use or adapt any part of this guide? (optional)

Corrections (include the page or section)

A wrong number, a broken reference, a misattributed example.

Contact (optional)

Only if you would like a reply or are open to a follow-up conversation.

Please answer the two required questions above.

Thank you

Your comments were submitted. Comments received by November 30 inform the January revision, and we will publish a summary of what we heard and what changed.